Advantages And Disadvantages Of Joint Family

Growing up in a joint family can have a significant influence on a child. So, is a joint family setup the right choice? Examine the characteristics of a joint family and take an informed decision.

By Moina Memon  • 10 min read

Advantages And Disadvantages Of Joint Family
Sharing laughter and tears, together  

“The joint family is a beautiful institution” -- most of us have grown up to listening to this idea and believing in it as well. Our movies portray a joint family as one where everyone eats together, laughs together and supports each other during both good and bad times.

Like every other social system, the joint family system also has its share of advantages and disadvantages. But, the importance of a joint family is still acknowledged by many.

What is a joint family?

In India, a joint family is usually a large undivided family where members of more than one generation live together under one roof (grandparents, parents, uncles, aunts and their children).

As with every system, the family structure is also evolving. Some reasons for this change are scarcity of living space, increase in the number of households where both partners work, a jump in the number of single parents and so on. But, even with changing times, a sizable number of Indians still seem to be inclined towards the joint family system.

So, is the joint family a good or bad system? Let's delve in deeper to understand what is keeping this old system alive, evolving and relevant.

Advantages of a joint family

  • Togetherness: Growing up with cousins, uncles, aunts and grandparents gives children the opportunity to connect with everyone and forge close bonds. Especially, the bond with grandparents, which almost every child cherishes. This feature is among the key characteristics of a joint household.
  • Imbibing family values: Many values that parents want to teach children are taught well in the joint household. Growing up together, children learn to share, care for and respect everyone. They also learn how to empathise with those around them.
  • Shared support system: For working parents, who need someone trustworthy to be around their children, this family system is a boon. With uncles, aunts or grandparents around, who care for children and have their best interest in mind, parents feel less worried. Thus, they have the freedom to make time to socialise, catch up with each other at a private dinner, or hang out with friends.
  • Division of labour: A big family works like a big team, especially when it comes to doing household chores like cooking or cleaning. Family members get together and ensure that tasks are done on time and, sometimes, even before time. As a result, no family member ever feels stressed about work.
  • Financial security: All the earning family members contribute to the common fund for household expenses. This system also acts as a security net. When a member suffers monetary loss or loss of job, others get together to ensure that his or her daily needs are taken care of.

Disadvantages of a joint family

  • Lack of together time/privacy: With many family members around, the lack of privacy and/or together time, can become an issue. If a particular family member is called up frequently to shoulder responsibilities, it can lead to disharmony in married life. Also, in a joint household, a couple always has to be mindful about being watched and heard when they want to exchange a compliment or a gesture or, engage in a discussion or an argument.
  • Decreased freedom to express: A couple, especially the woman, might struggle with finding her comfort zone outside her room. She might not have a say in many aspects like deciding on food choices, decorating the house or even, wearing something that is comfortable for her and stepping out of her room. At times, her ideas might also be dismissed by other family members.
  • Disagreement on finances: Contributions towards running the household and how the money should be spent is a major issue in joint households. While everyone is expected to contribute money towards running the house, it is the head of the family who controls the funds and decides on how the money will be spent. Sometimes, the decisions taken by the head of the family may not go down well with some family members, leading to disagreements and arguments.
  • Conflicts over parenting style: Parenting becomes a challenge in a big family. Many adults with differing styles may bombard parents with advice on what to do and what not. There might be interference in almost everything related to childcare and upbringing, right from use of diapers to food to disciplining. For a new mom, such intrusions can prove even more confusing and upsetting.
  • Discontent and distress: Over a period, all the above factors might lead to discontent and unhappiness among members of the family. Along with these, even trivial issues like not being able to make a dish as per one’s own recipe or inviting a friend over for a birthday bash, can snowball into a confrontation. At times, a family member may try to take undue advantage of others, which can also cause immense frustration. Also, those who earn more than others may try to dominate, leading to friction among family members.

Characteristics of a joint family

  • The family is usually headed by the eldest member of the family.
  • The responsibility of making decisions rests with the head of the family, although family members can give suggestions.
  • The family members share a single kitchen
  • All the members are expected to contribute financially towards running the family.
  • All the members have to share the household chores.
  • They should cooperate with and support each other, making the system have its share of both merits and demerits.
  • After marriage, the children also live in the same house along with other family members.

Importance of a joint family

Even in this age of nuclear family, the joint family system exists and remains relevant. Here is why the importance of joint family remains undiminished:

  • Teaches cooperation and optimum use of resources
  • Helps members understand and bond with each other
  • Teaches the concept “one for all and all for one”
  • Elders feel wanted and supported

Types of joint family

According to M S Gore, an Indian social scientist, the joint family can be of six types. These are:

  • Collateral joint family
  • Supplemented collateral joint family
  • Lineal joint family
  • Supplemented lineal joint family
  • Lineal collateral joint family
  • Supplemented lineal - collateral joint family

The HUF Act

The relevance of the joint family can be guessed from the fact that there is a HUF (Hindu Undivided Family) Act in India. This law states that a Hindu family can come together and create a HUF. However, all the members of a HUF should descend from a common ancestor. Along with other advantages, a HUF also enjoys tax benefits. Buddhists, Jains and Sikhs can also form a HUF.

Preferred family structure

No system in the world is a perfect system, and the same is true for a joint family also. However, having said that, there are families that make the system work by demarcating responsibilities and duties, respecting each other, and being generous and helpful. At the end, it boils down to what we want for ourselves and our children, and what is feasible.

About the author:

Written by Moina Memon on 25 February 2019.

Ms Memon is a writer and founder of Mommy Mojo blog. 

Looking for expert tips and interesting articles on parenting? Subscribe now to our magazine. Connect with us on Facebook | Twitter | Instagram | YouTube